- Ultra smooth and creamy formula that glides on easily
- Waterproof, smudge-proof, sweat-proof, heat-proof, humidity-proof
- Safe for sensitive eyes
This is a good color for the darker eyed gals out there like I am. When I do a smokey-eye look with my shadows I will take a small water line from my inner eye to about halfway to brighten my eyes up a little. It’s a great compliment to the outer eye dark smoky look. I wear this with contacts and have no sensitivity with it. The downside is, I’m not sure I would classify this as waterproof as by the end of the day I find that a lot of it has worn/smudged off. I would have thought that being waterproof would mean it could hold up to the water line, but maybe I was expecting too much. All in all, it’s not a bad liner.
Can be used as a concealer too
I read about this eyeliner in a magazine, but instead of using it for it’s intended purpose, they suggested using it as a concealer. I was intrigued by this idea and decided to give it a try. It applies smoothly and the fine tip is perfect for covering up minor blemishes. I was hoping that since this is formulated as an eyeliner that it would really stay put, unfortunately it does not. It has a very creamy texture and like other reviewers who actually used it as an eyeliner have stated, it just doesn’t stay on very long. It is okay, but not great. Perhaps I will use it as an eyeliner to see if I like it that way better.
Waterproof? I dont THINK so !!!
The reason I wanted a waterproof eyeliner is because most eyeliners give me raccoon eyes soon after applying, so I usually don’t use them. So I was advised to get a waterproof one. This "waterproof" liner smears and smudges more than non-waterproof ones I have tried . Too bad because it did go on nice, easy, and smooth. But for what ? What’s weird is that the actual SMUDGES wouldn’t budge so easy, so I’m having to wipe my eyes real hard to get it off, not good. This eyeliner truly SUCKS. Boooooooo !!!!
I wanted to love this eyeliner, it makes my eyes look so much bigger and more awake, but literally I blink and it’s gone from my waterline! I’ve even tried it on my upper lash line with a primer, nope, still fades away within minutes. My eyelids aren’t THAT oily either..The only way I can see this working is if you carry it around in your purse and keep checking a mirror and reapplying and reapplying… Really, though who has the time for that..Such a shame because it’s inexpensive, the color is beautiful, it has a nice, creamy consistency and glides on super smooth, but it just does not last.
no staying power
I love the color of this eyeliner. It looks so great, opens up the eye and on the lid it looks super subtle but very cute. It glides on smooth but DOESNT stay at ALL on my oily lids. I just wish they made it in a liquid liner because these kohl’s just don’t do it for me at all. Not in the water line and not on the lid… just doesn’t stay at all. I have very oily eyelids and this lasts not even 10 minutes. I’m sorry but I can’t justify a purchase that doesn’t last an hour!
Love this eyeliner
I love this eyeliner, it goes on so easy and it looks great. I purchased this to do the inside water line and corner of my eye, it matches skin tone well and works great. I am very happy with the quality of this liner and will probably buy other colors from Rimmel.
AMAZING!! Stays put on waterline til I wash it off and doesn’t harm my sensitive eyes!
I bought this on a whim cause I loved the color and it looked creamy and smooth, but I was nervous cause so many makeup products irritate my eyes, especially on my waterline (even a previous white Rimmel pencil irritated my waterline so bad my eyes watered up and turned red).My current waterline pencil is Tarte Emphaseyes in a nude color which does not irritate my eyes, but doesnt last long at all.So this Rimmel pencil goes on soooo smooth and silky, more so then any pencil I ever used. The color is perfect, it really opens my eyes and gives me bigger, brighter eyes. I worked a long work day and it remained on my waterline! I took a shower and washed my hair (but not my face/makeup, I do that after my shower) and looked in the mirror and it was still on my waterline, about 12 hrs after I applied it. Unbelievable!! (Yes it came off easily after I washed my face).I highly recommend, though not all makeup works the same for everyone, this one is so awesome for me, and I love the staying power, but I love even more that it doesn’t irritate my eyes.
This is a great product, I definitely prefer it over white eyeliner and over some of my high end products. A definite recommend as long as they don’t change the formula!
Works well for water line
I use this along with my NYX milk eyeliner in my waterline to help me look more awake. Works wonders!